Raising Our Boys
“Boys and Learning” has been our faculty’s topic of study this year. We’ve read articles, engaged in discussions, listened to speakers, and dedicated workshop days to further our learning. I have to admit that thinking about what the world is like from a boy’s perspective, rather than looking at boys through the lens of a female has been an interesting shift.
I’m hoping that many of you were able to hear Dr. Michael Thompson speak at Breck in October I found him both insightful and informative. He is passionate about boys in our society and schools. Dr. Thompson spends a great deal of time helping parents and educators better understand how boys process emotions and what drives their behavior. His wisdom invited me to shift my thinking about boys in our culture.
Two things on my mind lately have to do with the way boys play and the societal messages they receive about feelings. When my son was a young boy, violence wasn’t allowed in our house- he never had a gun because my mantra was, “The only things guns do is kill.” He still managed to make a gun out of his toast pretty regularly (something my daughters never felt the need to do!). If my son were young today, I would reconsider my strident view. My shift in thinking has to do with understanding that the imaginative play of boys and girls is part of who they are. Healthy children can separate reality from imagination and do it all of the time. My son would have been no more likely to shoot a real gun as a seven year old, than I would have been to drive a convertible (in an evening gown) - because that’s what I played with my Barbies. From my female lens, I believed “playing” guns was qualitatively different from “playing” Barbies. I didn’t consider that my brothers and husband played with guns as boys, yet as adults are positive role models. The simple awareness that my mindset was based in my female perspective has given me “food for thought”.
Naming and validating the full range of emotions in boys is equally important to me. Children see and hear messages that are both subtle and overt about which feelings are acceptable for each gender. Often, boys receive the message that they need to be emotionally strong and stoic, while girls are viewed as more fragile. I watched a segment of Dr. Thompson’s PBS documentary "Raising Cain". Thompson noted that Katherine Weinberger, Ph.D., a researcher featured in the documentary, suggests that boys are more vulnerable and less resilient than girls in the first few months of life. He says, "Dr. Weinberger found that a higher proportion of girls could calm themselves when their mother's face displayed a 'stony expression' (as opposed to a warm one) — but that the boys could not. More boys would get easily distressed. They cried more frequently, and were unable to calm themselves. While we somehow expect boys to be 'tough,' this evidence shows them to actually be extremely vulnerable. This proves what we've known for years — that boys feel a full range of emotions — even those considered 'not masculine' like fear, shame, humiliation, and uncertainty. If everyone understood (as research now shows) that boys possess some emotional vulnerabilities that girls do not, would they raise them differently?"
All of this new information is causing me to rethink some long-held beliefs about boys. If you would like to read more about this topic, I think you’d find Dr. Thompson’s book Raising Cain informative. You can also watch segments of his PBS documentary at http://www.pbs.org/opb/raisingcain/.
I’m hoping that many of you were able to hear Dr. Michael Thompson speak at Breck in October I found him both insightful and informative. He is passionate about boys in our society and schools. Dr. Thompson spends a great deal of time helping parents and educators better understand how boys process emotions and what drives their behavior. His wisdom invited me to shift my thinking about boys in our culture.
Two things on my mind lately have to do with the way boys play and the societal messages they receive about feelings. When my son was a young boy, violence wasn’t allowed in our house- he never had a gun because my mantra was, “The only things guns do is kill.” He still managed to make a gun out of his toast pretty regularly (something my daughters never felt the need to do!). If my son were young today, I would reconsider my strident view. My shift in thinking has to do with understanding that the imaginative play of boys and girls is part of who they are. Healthy children can separate reality from imagination and do it all of the time. My son would have been no more likely to shoot a real gun as a seven year old, than I would have been to drive a convertible (in an evening gown) - because that’s what I played with my Barbies. From my female lens, I believed “playing” guns was qualitatively different from “playing” Barbies. I didn’t consider that my brothers and husband played with guns as boys, yet as adults are positive role models. The simple awareness that my mindset was based in my female perspective has given me “food for thought”.
Naming and validating the full range of emotions in boys is equally important to me. Children see and hear messages that are both subtle and overt about which feelings are acceptable for each gender. Often, boys receive the message that they need to be emotionally strong and stoic, while girls are viewed as more fragile. I watched a segment of Dr. Thompson’s PBS documentary "Raising Cain". Thompson noted that Katherine Weinberger, Ph.D., a researcher featured in the documentary, suggests that boys are more vulnerable and less resilient than girls in the first few months of life. He says, "Dr. Weinberger found that a higher proportion of girls could calm themselves when their mother's face displayed a 'stony expression' (as opposed to a warm one) — but that the boys could not. More boys would get easily distressed. They cried more frequently, and were unable to calm themselves. While we somehow expect boys to be 'tough,' this evidence shows them to actually be extremely vulnerable. This proves what we've known for years — that boys feel a full range of emotions — even those considered 'not masculine' like fear, shame, humiliation, and uncertainty. If everyone understood (as research now shows) that boys possess some emotional vulnerabilities that girls do not, would they raise them differently?"
All of this new information is causing me to rethink some long-held beliefs about boys. If you would like to read more about this topic, I think you’d find Dr. Thompson’s book Raising Cain informative. You can also watch segments of his PBS documentary at http://www.pbs.org/opb/raisingcain/.